Tag archive for "College Football Playoff"

April 14, 2011   |No Comments College Football Playoff

QUICK KICK: 21 Economists Agree, DOJ Should Investigate BCS

by Jeremiah Tittle

How many economists does it take to end a corrupt system’s reign over a publicly-funded institution like NCAA athletics?  The answer: 21(hopefully)

Our friends at Playoff PAC have once again pushed the envelope. This time, the target is the Department of Justice antitrust division. 21 prominent economists have sent a letter to the DOJ to investigate the BCS’s violation of antitrust laws. It’s about time that the government serve the people and push for Division I football follow suit with every other sport in the NCAA.

Read the Playoff PAC press release here.

Read the Wall Street Journal article here.

March 31, 2011   |1 Comment College Football Playoff

2011 Final Four Proves BCS is BS

by Brad Sullivan

It’s been an incredible NCAA Men’s Basketball Tournament this season, and the Final Four should be no exception. When you look at this year’s remaining teams, there are two teams that very few had advancing to this stage.

VCU and Butler have punched their ticket to Houston by taking down some of the highest-ranked, talent-flush teams in college basketball. The strong play of these underdogs proves once again that a playoff system is the best way to determine a champion. It is the most equitable method to determine who should take home the trophy.

In college football, the opportunity to win a national championship is only available to those who run in the same circles. A school must belong to a BCS conference to even be considered. Meanwhile, NCAA basketball shares the same equitable method to determine a champion as Division II Football, Division III Football, women’s field hockey, squash, and every other NCAA sport. You can get hot at the right time, make a run, and win a title. It’s the American way!

Unfortunately college football is more of a mafia cartel. The teams without the name will never have a chance to get hot and make a run due to the BCS. You’d think John Gotti himself set it up.

With the NFL in a lockout, College Football has a great opportunity to make some headway increasing their fan base, and what better way to grab more fans then by creating a playoff system?

We all know this won’t happen without pressure from the fans, but it would be epic. You would see some smaller programs get hot at the right time and run the table.

The fans will continue to be forced to watch lopsided routes and terrible teams play each other in terrible tradition-less bowl games rather than experience all the excitement and fairness of a single elimination playoffs system.

Michael Bradley Sullivan serves as an SFC Sportswriter Fellow. He is a senior broadcast journalism major at Texas Tech University in Lubbock, Texas. He was born and Raised in Corpus Christi, Texas. He is a fan of the Texas Tech Red Raiders, the Dallas Cowboys, and the San Antonio Spurs. Follow him on twitter here.

March 29, 2011   |No Comments College Football Playoff

Fiesta Bowl Fires CEO Junker, Releases Investigation Report

by Jeremiah Tittle

Fiesta Bowl CEO and President John Junker – one of the many villains who often float behind the scenes in the white collar crime spree we call the BCS system – was fired today.  Credit goes to Playoff PAC, who have spent months filing IRS complaints and working to show how the Fiesta Bowl — which is supposed to be a nonprofit — was lavishly spending, overcompensating its executives and illegally reimbursing politicians. An investigative report commissioned by the Fiesta Bowl’s Board of Directors was released today, showing these improprieties and  validating Playoff PAC’s efforts. Hat tip to them.

This scandal has BCS mess written all over it, and while we’d like to celebrate in times like these, it’s in our best interest as sports fans to take everything with a grain of salt. Do we really trust the other BCS Bowls to clean up their act because one got caught?

The answer is simple.  No.

As long as University presidents bank seven figure salaries and BCS conference schools rake in millions each year, there will be no change to the current system. That is unless and until we college football fans unite into one voice and strike fear into the powers that be. We need to hold their feet to the fire to correct these improprieties that continue to plague our inequitable, publicly-funded NCAA college football post-season debacle.

Read the press release here.

Join SportsFans.org today and let’s use our power wisely to fight for a playoff in NCAA Division I Football.

Jeremiah Tittle is the Managing Editor of SportsFans.org.  He graduated from the University of Maryland.  He is a fan of the Terps, the football team in the Washington, D.C. area, the Wizards, Manchester United, and Napoli.

Follow him at www.twitter.com/WWWJT.

Email him at Jeremiah@SportsFans.org.

[Note: An earlier version of this reported that "it was Playoff PAC and SportsFans.org’s own efforts putting pressure on this entity" that led to the revelations of the Fiesta Bowl improprieties. In fact, Playoff PAC deserves all the credit.  SportsFans.org has merely reported on Playoff PAC's efforts to force today's revelations.]

February 15, 2011   |No Comments College Football Playoff

QUICK KICK: Fiesta Bowl Investigated for Improper Donations

by Jonathan Maldonado

Current and former employees of the BCS’s Fiesta Bowl are being investigated in response to allegations of possible improper campaign donations. Reports on the matter indicate employees made contributions to friendly politicians towards political campaigns. Such contributions violate state and federal law.

Read the full story here.

January 21, 2011   |No Comments College Football Playoff

QUICK KICK: ESPN Buys A Football Team

by Mike Felten

The trend toward independent media deals for major universities continues. Notre Dame was the first. Texas has just signed a $300 million deal with ESPN. Nebraska left the Big XII in a quest for autonomy. An Oklahoma TV network is in the works.

This sports fan wonders once the media companies have enough for a league of their own if the BCS will turn into a beer softball league. The ESPN champions will be in a playoff versus Fox Sports, NBC versus ABC. Do you think the Boise State’s and TCU’s of the world will get a title chance then?

Read the story here.

Mike Felten is an SFC sportswriter fellow. He is a music industry veteran, a performer, and owner of the Landfill Records, the former Record Emporium, navigating the transitioning areas of intellectual property and musicians rights. Born and raised in Chicago, Mike is a long time Chicago Cubs fan and a Oklahoma Sooners booster.

January 17, 2011   |No Comments College Football Playoff

Who is the True National Champion?

by George Donnelly

Auburn University is proudly celebrating a national title in football after beating Oregon in the BCS National Championship Game.  Both teams absolutely deserved to be in the game; each won their conference championships by going undefeated while facing some of the best competition in the country each and every week. 

But while Auburn and Oregon were battling for the BCS Trophy, another undefeated team was at home.  Texas Christian University, home of the 2011 Rose Bowl Champion Horned Frogs, were 10 days removed from beating a favored Wisconsin team that ESPN Magazine had just labeled the best in the nation.  TCU also played a difficult schedule, defeating Utah on the road and Oregon State at home, amongst other notable victories.

The current BCS system, however, did not give TCU a chance to play for the national title.  Despite beating every team that they faced, the voters and computers that determine who plays in the national championship game.  So while TCU is able to celebrate a Rose Bowl victory and taunt Ohio State’s President with billboards in Columbus, they are unable to stake a claim to being national champions.

This is not to say that Auburn is not deserving of the title.  An undefeated season while playing in the SEC is certainly an amazing accomplishment.  But until there is a playoff system in college football, there will always be disagreements over which team deserves to be called national champs.  The students and residents of Auburn, Alabama are deservedly celebrating a national title.  However, there are thousands of people in Fort Worth, Texas who believe that their local university has the best team in the land.  

George Donnelly is the Local Chapter Chair of SFC Philadelphia and an SFC Sportswriter Fellow.  He is an 8th grade Math and Science teacher based in Philadelphia.  He graduated from the University of Pennsylvania and is a lifelong fan of the Phillies, Flyers, Sixers, and unfortunately the Eagles.

January 15, 2011   |No Comments College Football Playoff

Memories of Division III National Championship Games

by George Donnelly

I grew up in Glassboro, New Jersey, a small town about 30 minutes outside of Philadelphia.  Now, in the Mid-Atlantic and the Northeast, we don’t have too many powerhouse college football teams.  We have Penn State, but they are a few hours away and I never visited Beaver Stadium when I was younger.  Rutgers was good one year, but never competed in a major bowl game.  And Temple?  Until recently, they were the worst team in Division I football.

So my college football experience growing up revolved around the Rowan University football team.  Rowan, located in my hometown of Glassboro, had a powerhouse football team. They won the New Jersey Athletic Conference almost every year, and always competed in the Division III playoffs, a 16 team tournament that puts the top Division III teams in a bracket in order to determine a champion.

Now fortunately for me, Rowan was so good that they reached the Division III National Championship Game, the Amos Alonzo Staff Bowl five times in the 1990’s.  Unfortunately, they were the Buffalo Bills of Division III football; they were destroyed in the title game each time.

Nevertheless, each December my grandfather and I would make the trek to Salem, Virginia in order to watch the Rowan Profs play for the National Championship.  Going into each game, we knew that if Rowan somehow pulled out a win, they would be the undisputed National Champions of Division III football.  As I said earlier, the Profs broke my heart each time they reached the Staff Bowl.  But at the end of the game, there was never any doubt about who was the National Champion.

So when I started following Division I college football (now the Football Bowl Subdivision), I never understood how two different teams could be named the National Champion.  One year Michigan split the national title with Nebraska.  Another year, LSU won the National Championship given by the Coaches Poll and USC won the AP National Championship.  But how could two teams be National Champions?

This issue is just as baffling to me today.  There were three undefeated teams in the Football Bowl Subdivision after the regular season this year:  Auburn, Oregon, and TCU.  All three deserved a shot at the national title.  However, since only two teams can play in the national title game, Auburn and Oregon got their shot while TCU got to play in the Rose Bowl (a great consolation prize, but unfair nonetheless).  The fact that there is not a playoff system in the Football Bowl Subdivision is unacceptable.   A college football playoff was a big part of my childhood.  It should be a large part of the Football Bowl Subdivision as well.

George Donnelly is the Local Chapter Chair of SFC Philadelphia and an SFC Sportswriter Fellow.  He is an 8th grade Math and Science teacher based in Philadelphia.  He graduated from the University of Pennsylvania and is a lifelong fan of the Phillies, Flyers, Sixers, and unfortunately the Eagles.

January 11, 2011   |No Comments College Football Playoff

QUICK KICK: BCS Executive Director Torpedoes Playoff Option

by Scott Weiss

“BCS executive director Bill Hancock said college football is more likely to return to the old bowl system than having a playoff one beginning in the 2014 season.”  What this reminds me of is a totalitarian government saying, not only aren’t we granting increased freedom of speech, but any increased freedom that we previously granted is being revoked.  Hancock said that a playoff system is not even being considered.  The level of arrogance and disregard for public sentiment is startling.

Wouldn’t it be nice if college football fans exerted enough pressure on Mr. Hancock and his cronies to take the decision out of their hands completely?  Mr. Hancock, everyone including you knows that real champions are the ones who win their way through a playoff system.

Check out the entire AOL FanHouse story here.

Scott Weiss is the Local Chapter Chair for SFC-New York/New Jersey and an SFC Sportwriter Fellow. He has been involved in the sports fans advocacy movement since 2000. He is a life long fan of the Mets, Jets, Knicks, and Rangers.

January 10, 2011   |No Comments College Football Playoff

35th Bowl Game – Not a National Championship Game

by Scott Weiss

Make no mistake about it, tonight’s matchup between Auburn and Oregon is not a National Championship Game.  Yes, it is the 35th bowl game of the 2010-2011 college football season, but not a National Championship Game.  This is not about disrespecting Auburn University or the University of Oregon, or their loyal fans.  This is about not accepting the Bogus Championship Series, and its random way of picking a National Champion. 

As a matter of fact I have been inspired by the BCS to create my own College Football National Championship selection process.  It will be called, the Scott Weiss Random Championship Selection Process (SWRCSP).  For this year, I have named the Louisville Cardinals the National Champion.  How did I make this decision?  The answer is simple.  The Bowl Game that they won, the Beef ‘O’ Brady’s St. Petersburg Bowl, clearly has the coolest name of all the Bowl Games.

My criteria for next year’s champion will surely make as much sense as the process that I followed this year.  After all, remember my inspiration is the BCS.  Let’s see, maybe next year my criteria will be the team that won the bowl game with the most vowels in its title will be the National Champion.

Have you had enough of my over the top sarcasm?  I think the better question is, does my ridiculous parody really make any less sense than the way that the BCS selects their National Champion?  Here’s hoping that next year neither the BCS system or SWRCSP system decides the National Champion, but rather a legitimate and fair playoff system.

Scott Weiss is the Local Chapter Chair for SFC-New York/New Jersey and an SFC Sportwriter Fellow. He has been involved in the sports fans advocacy movement since 2000. He is a life long fan of the Mets, Jets, Knicks, and Rangers.

January 10, 2011   |No Comments College Football Playoff

QUICK KICK: Quack Jobs

by Chana Elgin 

You may think the BCS has reached its crazy limits- UConn against OU, LSU ripping that poor Aggie dog to shreds, but Steve Duin is humbly extending his blessings to the BCS gods.

Ok, sarcasm is hard to convey via text:

The BCS is the unapologetic triumph of market manipulation, geek math, insider training, queasy yellow sports jackets, stacked decks and Tostitos’ Creamy Spinach Dip over everything that matters.”

Not to mention, Stevie’s got the scoop on the $5,000 ticket prices and $2 million a minute advertisements. Ludicrous? Nah, I doubt he’ll be there, but I bet he thinks it’s ridiculous, too.

Duin may think Oregon’s got nothing to go on but a duck wing and a webbed-foot prayer, but he’s got the full incite into the BCS and the quack job it is. Read it here.

Chana Elgin is a junior broadcast journalism major at Texas Tech University. She is currently serving a Sportswriter Fellowship on behalf of the SFC. Hailing from Houston, Chana is a fan of all teams that are not Dallas.

© 2010 National Sports Fan Coalition. All rights reserved. Download SFC Bylaws (PDF).

Save Next Season Petition Terms and Conditions
All information you provide on this petition signing form will be public on the petition signatures page, except your email address, which will remain private. You may receive updates on this issue and other issues from Sports Fans Coalition though you're always welcome to unsubscribe anytime. Your email is always safe with us.