by George Donnelly
I grew up in Glassboro, New Jersey, a small town about 30 minutes outside of Philadelphia. Now, in the Mid-Atlantic and the Northeast, we don’t have too many powerhouse college football teams. We have Penn State, but they are a few hours away and I never visited Beaver Stadium when I was younger. Rutgers was good one year, but never competed in a major bowl game. And Temple? Until recently, they were the worst team in Division I football.
So my college football experience growing up revolved around the Rowan University football team. Rowan, located in my hometown of Glassboro, had a powerhouse football team. They won the New Jersey Athletic Conference almost every year, and always competed in the Division III playoffs, a 16 team tournament that puts the top Division III teams in a bracket in order to determine a champion.
Now fortunately for me, Rowan was so good that they reached the Division III National Championship Game, the Amos Alonzo Staff Bowl five times in the 1990’s. Unfortunately, they were the Buffalo Bills of Division III football; they were destroyed in the title game each time.
Nevertheless, each December my grandfather and I would make the trek to Salem, Virginia in order to watch the Rowan Profs play for the National Championship. Going into each game, we knew that if Rowan somehow pulled out a win, they would be the undisputed National Champions of Division III football. As I said earlier, the Profs broke my heart each time they reached the Staff Bowl. But at the end of the game, there was never any doubt about who was the National Champion.
So when I started following Division I college football (now the Football Bowl Subdivision), I never understood how two different teams could be named the National Champion. One year Michigan split the national title with Nebraska. Another year, LSU won the National Championship given by the Coaches Poll and USC won the AP National Championship. But how could two teams be National Champions?
This issue is just as baffling to me today. There were three undefeated teams in the Football Bowl Subdivision after the regular season this year: Auburn, Oregon, and TCU. All three deserved a shot at the national title. However, since only two teams can play in the national title game, Auburn and Oregon got their shot while TCU got to play in the Rose Bowl (a great consolation prize, but unfair nonetheless). The fact that there is not a playoff system in the Football Bowl Subdivision is unacceptable. A college football playoff was a big part of my childhood. It should be a large part of the Football Bowl Subdivision as well.
George Donnelly is the Local Chapter Chair of SFC Philadelphia and an SFC Sportswriter Fellow. He is an 8th grade Math and Science teacher based in Philadelphia. He graduated from the University of Pennsylvania and is a lifelong fan of the Phillies, Flyers, Sixers, and unfortunately the Eagles.